![]() |
AMD ATI HD3300 vs Intel/Nvidia GF9400 - Printable Version +- Kodi Community Forum (https://forum.kodi.tv) +-- Forum: Discussions (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=222) +--- Forum: Hardware (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=112) +--- Thread: AMD ATI HD3300 vs Intel/Nvidia GF9400 (/showthread.php?tid=61042) |
AMD ATI HD3300 vs Intel/Nvidia GF9400 - lucky - 2009-11-07 Ok ive read heaps of posts searched the forum for similar posts and I believe the only answer is to create a new post - so if youre going to flame me know that i have tried... and if i got it wrong i accept its my fail. Ive been using xbmc on an xbox for many years hooked up to a server, its reached retirement for the usual list of reasons. Im speccing out a htpc box and i need to make fundamental choices and im confused. REQUIREMENTS 1/ it must run xbmc 2/ reasonably future proof, headroom for graphics, cpu, sound etc 3/ it must play HD content 4/ i would like at some point to use it for gaming. 5/ i would prefer to run win7. (im not adverse to xbmc live via usb) and here is the $5million question, which platform: AMD/ati Motherboard - DFI LANParty JR-790GX-M3H5 CPU - AMD PhenomII X3 720 BE (2.8Ghz AM3) Intel/Nvidia motherboard - DFI LANParty JR-GF9400-T2RS CPU - Intel Core2Duo E7500 (2.93Ghz lga775) from the forums i understand that vdpau is only supported under linux nvidia but surely the amd solution is more than fast enough? basically of the above 2 the e7500 is slower but the 790gx/sb750 chipset lacks 8.1 support. to start out i will be using the IGP but later ill add some sort of sli/crossfire setup. so opinions suggestions etc. - jmarshall - 2009-11-07 The latter for sure. ATI graphics == suck. - lucky - 2009-11-07 awesome i got a dev reply... now that i have an audience... can you elaborate on why ati sux, anandtech has the ati setup outperforming the nvidia on almost every bench (similar conclusion at toms), and the amd chip is a much better performer than the e7500. the price is way cheaper too. http://www.anandtech.com/mb/showdoc.aspx?i=3432&p=4 http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/amd-785g-chipset,2381-16.html does it suck for xbmc ? for some particular reason youve experienced Thanks! - adamvh - 2009-11-07 Well if your planning to run xbmc under linux which most people desire to. ATI linux support is somewhat of a mess atm with several different x server drivers. I recently turned my Asus Laptop W2W with ATI HD2600 Mobility into a media ceter running xbmc. And getting ATI running was a nightmare and in the end I found out the radeon driver didn't support audio over hdmi and radeonhd had bad colour tearing for me. The ATI propitary driver didn't work. http://wiki.x.org/wiki/radeon http://wiki.x.org/wiki/radeonhd http://www.radeonhd.org/ So yer basically to sum it up ati driver support under linux depending on the card isn't worth the effort. I Recently purchased an Asrock ION 330 and litteraly was a sinch compared to the 50 odd hours I had to put into getting the W2W running properly which ended up compiling latest drivers from git and to get something functional :/ ohh yer and VDPAU ftw! - adamvh - 2009-11-07 Worth reading is.. http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=amd_xvba_vaapi&num=1 Quote:Published on November 03, 2009 - lucky - 2009-11-07 ok so im completely well and truly clear that amd/ati under linux is close to impossible/futile. but what about win7 ? - jmarshall - 2009-11-07 On win7 you *might* be OK. Note that hardware decoding isn't going to be happening in the short-term (3 months?) at least on windows anyway. Longer term, sure. ATI drivers in my experience suck. Enable vsync on Win XP SP3 (seems to be irrelevant what driver you're using) and you have 100% CPU usage as it spins waiting for vsync. I suspect it may not be as bad in Vista and Win7, purely because we don't have to use exclusive mode there, and windowed mode doesn't seem to suffer the same problem. Cheers, Jonathan - darkscout - 2009-11-09 Get a feature set C video card. Nvidia GT210/GT220. Decodes more in hardware. I never broke 10% CPU. - Geeba - 2009-11-09 Ahhhh now I'm in the market for a GFX card for my Live setup.... GT210/GT220 is theway to go then? - RKMFlorida - 2009-11-12 Yes, absolutely, I cannot say enough about my 210 w/XBMC. In fact, I've just posted about it a few times on this forum, I'm so happy with it. |