I will read up on the differences on dialog vs window in this particular context because clearly it means something very different in Kodi land.
I am going to say something and preface it with this disclaimer of absolution of: "I mean absolutely no disrespect, negative connotation, or derogatory statements"..... but from the outside looking in, while the wiki is
very comprehensive text wise, overall, it is and overall has been very unhelpful, on many topics (for me at least).
I realize it is completely community driven, voluntarily updated, and I think that mostly landed on Karellen shoulders since I know he does most of the updates, so again,
absolutely no disrespect to him or anyone else who updates it...none... none whatsoever...I'm speaking about content absorption or availability itself from an
inexperienced user perspective.
The reason I say that is this and it has been a trend I've seen in the forums, everyone is consistently told to use confluence skin to "learn" from etc. and ok, that makes sense, but you have to
know what questions to ask before you start to dissect something or even know where to begin. When you see Kodi and you are like, I'd love to do that etc., and you when realize the learning curve... well, it can be, discouraging....
but the true crux of the matter is this.... NEARLY THE ENTIRE WIKI IS TEXT BASED. Who in the hell is going to read that, understand that, and correlate what that even means in relation to confluence skin while trying to sort out VSCODE (or IDE of choice), syntax highlighting, data management, versioning, blah blah blah... unless your already in the biz... we already have our answer....very few and dwindling.
The problem with the skinning manual, and you're going to laugh (
please laugh and loudly), there are no pictures! SHOW ME what is happening, the pictures that are there are for transitions or things that are fluff, or better yet, local videos of the topic at hand, nobody wants to drudge through wiki hundreds of lines of <left> blah </left> bs in text and have to correlation to what is happening in real time ON THE SCREEN, for example... label1 & label2 of what that even means, in Kodi land, and why. Something so stupid like the system information panel on label2, 3 lines of Kodi information, is like 30 xml lines of code to create a simple feedback to the user... it is maddening to try and swallow that and retain it...
These are not excuses in any way, not meant to in any way make anyone's hard work or efforts belittled, no way, it is just my I wanna be a skinner observation from the ground up warts and all. I know you folks hear lots of negative shit, a lot of it unwarranted, but you guys have a great platform, and I can see the forest for the trees, my problem is I'm barely crawling and I want to run like Hussain bolt and I'm pissed I can't because I'm a god in my world and a peasant in this one....so it is frustrating.
So please don't be upset or think less because of this post, it is simply an observation of the skinning manual, because I have many times gone to it, tried to see how to apply it, and walked away wanting and went to Google to see if I could find an example of what would match what I'm doing. I have multiple bookmarks dedicated to skin dev, between window ids, control ids, skinning manual, infolables, your GitHub, jurialmonkey's github and multiple others...
As I'm a believer in being part of the solution when a perceived problem is detected and not just sit and complain about it, my thoughts would be at some point, when "I" better understand how some of these things work that I would create video tutorials (which clearly you see I like to do...LOL) that you guys could review and if they make sense, either YT them, local load, or host them where ever and link them from the wiki as part of enhancement to explain each submodule to actual "show" what each thing does. Many people learn leaps and bounds when they can visualize what is going on and I think that might help many people out because the work you've done with me certainly has proven that concept out. Something to think about for the future maybe.
Anyway, don't want this to seem like a cry baby fest, it isn't and certainly don't want anyone to look at me in a negative light, I plan to stick around and plan to help others once I can get my own head above water, so please understand it is all coming from the heart and not meant to be viewed any other way.
Thx for listening and again, your support.
Chris