Posts: 708
Joined: Feb 2009
Reputation:
144
This is the neatest manager I've come across yet.... its tidy and fast and does what it says on the tin!! superb.
I'm still playing with it, but a couple of comments so far:
1) would be nice to have a checkbox column for 'subtitles'
2) might be nice to have checkbox columns user specified files
3) it's not at all clear when a 'save' is happening... I think an explicit 'save button' after an edit is more reassuring (and less fearful that if you screw up, the app hasn't already saved it!)
4) might be nice to see all the 'active' artwork for a movie (fanart, poster etc)
5) not sure if there are 'glitches' in the handling of stacked movies... need to check this for sure
I must again say "SUPERB". It truly is. No criticism of the other efforts, but as you say some seem to have grown and grown and become difficult to manage. A rewrite is usually twice as simple, half the size, and twice as manageable.
Posts: 72
Joined: Nov 2008
Reputation:
0
2009-05-08, 01:42
(This post was last modified: 2009-05-08, 02:20 by sumofatguy.)
After using it a bit for my whole movie collection, I really like how simple and quick it is to use. I do have a few comments though thus far which may already be in the works, but I just thought I would mention them:
1. Ignore the folder $RECYCLE.BIN
2. Maybe have the location of the selected movie displayed in the bottom status bar (ie h:\HD\movie)
3. Auto-rescan when, for instance, a movie is missing fanart and you add it manually
4. Have a 'recently added' checkbox above/below the list of movies for easy changes to new movies
Other than those for now, its working wonderfully for me! Good work
Posts: 708
Joined: Feb 2009
Reputation:
144
2009-05-08, 02:24
(This post was last modified: 2009-05-08, 02:34 by AnalogKid.)
Ok, the issue with stacked movies is that <moviename> - CDx causes the app to assume there's no nfo, and no poster, although it does find fanart... strange!
In such a circumstance, the nfo will be <moviename>.nfo without the ' - CDx' part.
I think if you can omit the '-CDx' or ' - CDx' it'll work fine. You might have to check for all variants of stacking formats, but I think those two are the most common.
Another minor point... if you've downloaded an NFO for a file, or artwork etc via the app, then it might be worth updating the checkbox to show that it now exists (otherwise, you have to do a rescan to update the indicators correctly)
And finally (for the moment), it looks like you're using case sensitive string matching to see if NFO's and tbn's exist etc... I'd recommended insensitive matching, but I can see this might be deliberate too...
You did WANT feedback right? ;-)
Posts: 875
Joined: Oct 2008
Reputation:
14
nul7
Posting Freak
Posts: 875
Thanks for all the feedback. I'll sort through everything later tonight. I'm working on the code to extract video frames now. I had already written a complete API video player/frame extractor, but it didn't work on video types such as divx, mkv, etc. Sucked. Now I'm working with ffmpeg.... but it's sooooo slow. Does anyone have any suggestions??
Posts: 875
Joined: Oct 2008
Reputation:
14
nul7
Posting Freak
Posts: 875
Well, I'd like to allow the user to select exactly which frame to extract. I've worked it all out though.... well, that is if nobody minds requiring directx to be installed. lol
Posts: 889
Joined: Jan 2008
Reputation:
11
Why grab keyframes? There's no reason that a thumb on a keyframe would be any more relevant than a thumb on any other frame.